Rare And Collectible Sesame Street Items

Showing 20 out of 54939
Click here to view all


average price

36.52

low

5.00

high

4,750.00

Palisades Sesame Street Series 1 Prototype Ernie Guy Smiley Two Headed Monster
CollectionHero
Very Rare. Made in 2004-2005 Palisades canceled this line. Guy Smiley and â??Two Headed Monster. Letter â??Dâ?.
from CollectionHero
4750.00 USD 2025-11-20
Vintage Lot Of 2 Snuffy Snuffleupagus Sesame Street Applause / Knickerbocker
CollectionHero
Vintage Lot Of 2 Snuffy Snuffleupagus Sesame Street Applause 4 inches tall / Knickerbocker 16 inches tall
from CollectionHero
4499.00 USD 2025-11-20
Palisades Sesame Street - Muppets Prototype Ernie Guy Smiley Two Headed Monster
CollectionHero
Very Rare. Made in 2004-2005 Palisades canceled this line. Guy Smiley and â??Two Headed Monster. Letter â??Dâ?.
from CollectionHero
3750.00 USD 2025-11-20
TICKLE ME ELMO PLUSH BATTERY OPERATED SESAME STREET HASBRO PLAYSCHOOL LAUGHING
CollectionHero
This is a listing for 1 Plush, battery operated Red Tickle me Elmo character doll. He is a Sesame character, & is by Hasbro. He is part of PlaySkool Friends.  We will include extra batteries. Message us with anyquestions Thanks!
Name Brand items make great gifts.  PLEASE include the destination ZIP CODE with any questions about postage PayPal is the ONLY payment method accepted Payment must be made within 2 days of purchase.  This item will be relisted and, a non-paying bidder report will be filled with eBay if payment is not received withi
from CollectionHero
2999.00 USD 2025-11-20
The Muppets/Sesame Street Grover Puppet Replica  1/1 Professionally Built
CollectionHero
The Muppets/Sesame Street Grover Puppet Replica 1/1 Professionally Built - Sold on eBay Oct, 5th 2019 for $2,500.00
from CollectionHero
2500.00 USD 2025-11-20
Medicom Bearbrick 2021 Sesame Street Cookie Monster Costume 1000% Be@rbrick Elmo
CollectionHero
Hello Everyone! The picture you see is exactly the item you get! Bearbrick Fans must collect them all. Don't miss this chance!
from CollectionHero
2229.99 USD 2025-11-20
VINTAGE 1970'S HUGE 6' TALL FIBERGLASS BIG BIRD STATUE SESAME STREET VERY RARE
CollectionHero
Early 1970s Made -Rare ! Great for any Collector !
from CollectionHero
1800.00 USD 2025-11-20
Palisades Sesame Street Muppets Prototype Two Headed Monster 2HM Painted RARE
CollectionHero
Palisades Sesame Street Muppets Prototype Two Headed Monster 2HM Painted RARE. What you see is exactly what you get. This a painted 1st shot prototype.  Unproduced Palisades Sesame Street Two-Headed Monster. Yes, I do have the certificate of authenticity. Let me know if you're interested. No trades but will consider reasonable offers. Please know I'm happy holding onto this so don't take offense if I don't accfor your offer.
from CollectionHero
1600.00 USD 2025-11-20
New BACKSTAGE AT THE MUPPET SHOW Rowlf MUPPETS Palisades SUPER DELUXE PLAYSET
CollectionHero
Made by Palisades Toys in 2004. The weight of the other playsets has caused the box to buckle at the bottom and top. These are photos of theACTUAL ITEM you are purchasing. I put a can of Coke next to the box to show how big it is!
from CollectionHero
1299.95 USD 2025-11-20
Sesame Street General Store Metal Sign Ernie & Bert's Place NICE ! RARE!
CollectionHero
Sesame Street General Store Metal Sign Ernie & Bert's Place NICE ! RARE! 

I got this when the Sesame Street General Stores closed in 1998. A shame, I loved getting my cool Sesame Street stuff there as I am a big, big fan. This, however, I no longer have room for and actually never did get to display. Would look great near your children's area. Although it is metal, I believe that it is made for inside as it was in a mall for most of its life until I put it away in my attic. It is in very good condition, with only a couple of nicks out of the green paint and the decal peelin
from CollectionHero
1299.00 USD 2025-11-20
Vintage Fisher Price Little People Lot Over 1000 Pieces Huge Collection RARE pcs
CollectionHero
Vintage Fisher Price Little People Lot Over 1000 Pieces Huge Collection RARE pcs - Sold on eBay Oct, 23rd 2019 for $1,224.99
from CollectionHero
1224.99 USD 2025-11-20
New BACKSTAGE AT THE MUPPET SHOW Rowlf MUPPETS Palisades SUPER DELUXE PLAYSET
CollectionHero
New BACKSTAGE AT THE MUPPET SHOW Rowlf MUPPETS Palisades SUPER DELUXE PLAYSET. Tape is intact, toy is new and hasnâ??t been opened. There are some dings , creases, small tears as shown in pics. Mainly just overall wear from age storage being moved. Please ask questions fi you have them.
from CollectionHero
1199.99 USD 2025-11-20
The Muppets Kermit The Frog Master Replicas Photo Puppet Quality Reproduction
CollectionHero
Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for The Muppets Kermit The Frog Master Replicas Photo Puppet Quality Reproduction at the best online prices at eBay! Free shipping for many products!
from CollectionHero
1199.00 USD 2025-11-20
Sesame Street Big Bird Kiddie Ride Arcade Amusement Coin Operated. 100% Working!
CollectionHero
Sesame Street Big Bird Kiddie Ride Arcade Amusement Coin Operated. 100% Working! - Sold on eBay Jul, 12th 2019 for $1,015.00
from CollectionHero
1015.00 USD 2025-11-20
16'' Sesame Street Plush Elmo Stuff Animal Soft
CollectionHero
16'' Sesame Street Plush Elmo Stuff Animal Soft - Sold on eBay Oct, 30th 2019 for $1,000.00
from CollectionHero
1000.00 USD 2025-11-20
NANCO SESAME STREET - Animal PLUSH Muppets (54
CollectionHero
GREAT CON. NEAR MINT !
from CollectionHero
1000.00 USD 2025-11-20
Kaws BFF Pink Plush Pre-order New Deadstock Supreme Bape
CollectionHero
Kaws BFF Pink Plush Pre-order New Deadstock Supreme Bape - Sold on eBay Apr, 9th 2019 for $999.99
from CollectionHero
999.99 USD 2025-11-20
Sesame Street Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo, Talking, Laughing 10-Inch Plush Toy
CollectionHero
Sesame Street Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo, Talking, Laughing 10-Inch Plush Toy for Toddlers, Kids 12 Months & Up , RedMINI TICKLE ME ELMO: Perfectly-sized for take-along playtime adventures with all the iconic Tickle Me Elmo laughs you know and loveELMO LOVES TO LAUGH: Squeeze Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo’s tummy for giggly good times. Kids will love to laugh along with their favorite friend from Sesame Street.6 FUN PHRASES AND LAUGHS: For tons of furry monster fun, this giggling and talking Elmo toy features 6 phrases and laughs when you press his bellySOFT & CUDDLY: Sized just-right for little hugs, kids will love snuggling their super-soft Sesame Street Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo plush toyGREAT TOY FOR KIDS AGES 12 MONTHS AND UP: A fun gift for birthdays and holidays, this lovable Sesame Street Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo doll is a cuddly pal for kids ages 12 months and up. Surface Clean Only.Product a teeny-tiny Tickle Me Elmo — featuring all the iconic Elmo laughs you know and love! Sesame Street Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo is small enough to tag-along on playtime adventures, while kids squeeze his tummy for giggly good times: “Ha ha ha! That tickles Elmo!” Playing with Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo is so much fun, kids can’t help but laugh along with their furry monster friend from Sesame Street. This talking Elmo toy features 6 cute phrases and laughs when you press his belly: “Again! Again!” And since he’s perfectly-sized for little hugs, kids will love cuddling this soft, plush Elmo doll. Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo also makes a favorite little companion for kids ages 12 months and up — and it’s a great toy or gift for birthdays and holidays!Sesame Street and associated characters, trademarks, and design elements are owned and licensed by Sesame Workshop.Hasbro and all related terms are trademarks of Hasbro.Sesame Street Little Laughs Tickle Me ElmoIt’s a teeny-tiny Tickle Me Elmo — featuring all the iconic Elmo laughs you know and love! Sesame Street Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo is small enough to tag-along on playtime adventures, while kids squeeze his tummy for giggly good times: “Ha ha ha! That tickles Elmo!” Playing with Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo is so much fun, kids can’t help but laugh along with their furry monster friend from Sesame Street. This talking Elmo toy features 6 cute phrases and laughs when you press his belly: “Again! Again!” And since he’s perfectly-sized for little hugs, kids will love cuddling this soft, plush Elmo doll. Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo also makes a favorite little companion for kids ages 12 months and up — and it’s a great toy or gift for birthdays and holidays!MINI TICKLE ME ELMOPerfectly sized for take-along playtime adventures with all the iconic Tickle Me Elmo laughs you know and loveELMO LOVES TO LAUGHSqueeze Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo’s tummy for giggly good times! Kids will love to laugh along with their favorite friend from Sesame StreetSOFT & CUDDLYSized just-right for little hugs, kids will love snuggling their super-soft Sesame Street Little Laughs Tickle Me Elmo plush toy (Condition: Brand New)
from CollectionHero
999.00 USD 2025-11-20
Vintage 70’s PLAZA SESAMO - SESAME STREET Enamel Stage Set Prop Sign Jim Henson
CollectionHero
Vintage 70’s PLAZA SESAMO - SESAME STREET Enamel Stage Set Prop Sign Jim Henson - Sold on eBay Sep, 18th 2019 for $950.00
from CollectionHero
950.00 USD 2025-11-20
Vintage 1970's Sesame Street Muppet puppets (set of 10) HERRY, ROOSEVELT, GROVER
CollectionHero
Will ONLY sell as group. Please do not inquire about selling individual items. 
Complete set of 1970's Sesame Street Muppet puppets:
Roosevelt Franklin with box and arm stickAnything Muppet with box, arm stick and unopened facial features and unused hair piecesCookie Monster with boxOscar the Grouch with boxThe Count with box (some discolouration on his eyes)Grover (no box)Herry Monster (no box)Big Bird (no box and repair to internal rubber (no box)Bert (no box and some wear to nose) 
Please see photos and ask questions before you buy.
Thank
from CollectionHero
950.00 USD 2025-11-20


Click here to view all